Replies:
Yes of course privatization of public sectors leads to some healthy changes in an org. b's when you take public sectors u can find some slackness (or a little bit) delay in their services. But in case of private since service is there first and foremost duty they act rapidly.
Hi All,
Privatization of public sector. Lot depends of which sector we are talking about. Let me clarify few doubts in the primary stage. Can we expect all private hospitals in our cities in our town which do not have an entry for poor people, can we have only private sector telephone companies, can we have private companies have complete control on oil reserves, can we have all transport be provided by private sector and RTC vanishes, can we expect an private sector to take care of our defense. In the same way we cant expect the government to set up an IT industry on its own, we cant expect them to handle all the load of flight transport. My point over here is both are not mutually exclusive. We need to accept the fact that both are here to stay and we cannot make it without one. They do have their importance and we need to deal this issue according to the context.
There are some strategic sectors, which need to be under control of Indian government like oil/gas sector. The subsidy we enjoy will be never provided by a private sector. The government in this case helps its citizens to a great extent and making them available to its citizens. The ration card system is a great boon to the poor. Coming to some sectors like steel and mobile where both are present and a healthy competition among them always benefits the customers. It is also a point to be noted that Government itself cannot take the complete load just like it cant take the load of all flight customers where private sector is playing its helping role. Then there is education sector, which also has good competition with CBSE matching with any education system of either state syllabus or the schools coming up with their own syllabus. The public transport sector too is a mix of public and private and here you can see a striking difference. You can easily differentiate the profit motive of private personal whose salaries depend on the profit to their owner. In autos you can see some 6-8 people are dumped then starts the engine. I do accept that some services are best in private sector as they fear their job loss and their owners do get the best out of them by making them to work more no. Of hours.
The lazy mindset of some public sector could be taken into account to convert it to a private sector. I would like to suggest that counseling sessions for these to have a better future by working for the organization would help it to grow better and be under the public sector umbrella. We can take some examples by some of our previous strategies, which helped us to renovate dull companies, which lacked in performance. If a private individual is going to buy the company and could change its fortunes, why can't the public government do it? It can. Running away from a trouble is not a solution. Facing it head-on will produce better results.
I totally agree with Mr.ssrkraju.... As he said it depends on which sector we are talking about. And both have a different importance of their own. Privatization has its own proms and public sector have their own. I think both needs to be there as far today’s development is concerned.
Taking the view it is right that the work at public sectors is not working the way it should. But if everyone understands the responsibilities then it can also work the same way as private sectors. Again I think for some sectors it is ok otherwise it should be done by the respected ones itself...
POST YOUR VIEWS ON THIS TOPIC ......
|
said this on 09 Aug 2008 11:37:17 AM CST
Well friends, as we all know that most of the government units are known for their poor service level, that is why the private organisations are came in picture and even making huge profits out of the same customer base. The basic reason behind is the level of understanding, it means the junior level, middle level and the senior level management are not as much sharp or I should say not as professional as the private sector's all the level of management. Even the environment of the organisation is also matters.
By this point i just want to say that at each level of an organisation there should be an educated and highly professional person needs to be there. If we look at the features responsible for the success of private organisations we came to know that they at every level of management you will find a highly qualified and professional manager, and they set-up all the problems at their own level, so it is nothing but the power dilution and even the highest authority is wholly responsible for all the actions taken at every level of management.
|
|
said this on 23 Jan 2007 7:40:31 PM CST
Well friends, privtation is a very contentious issue. Just take the example of Private Hospitals, ther poor cant even think of getting a treatment there and if we do make all hospitals private then I can for sure say the people will die for treatment. And about the Power Industry, if its privatised, we are sure to get proper power supply but with increased rate per unit. The people of India made a huge hue and cry about the increasing petrol price and if the electricty rate are increased then look at the reaction.
|
|
said this on 28 Jan 2007 3:56:27 AM CST
i agree that public sector should be privatised..in private sector all things are handled more efficiently and effectively..more money is earned in case of private setor..hence we can hope to increase our salary i.e. average salary of the country will markedly
increase..which we can say to an extent that our country will develop at a faster rate..hospitals if privatised will result in better medical care..even if it is perceived as more costly as compared to govt. sectors..then let me give you an overview of things which are managed in hospitals...a patient if is poor is not dealt with utmost care and attention..is treated like a lowly thing...but had the patient been well off or had ministerial contacts then he will be given full care with all possible facilities..then wat is the use of public sector handling various institutions????
|
|
said this on 11 Feb 2007 8:10:35 PM CST
sir ur info is excellent.but i advice u to put the keypoints as first.bcaz if we want to search it takes too much of time.so plz give key with as possible as short.
thanks for give us this info
bye
|
|
said this on 12 Feb 2007 11:30:19 PM CST
IT WILL BE USEFUL IF SOME MORE POINTS ARE DISCUSSED UNDER THIS TOPIC
|
|
said this on 10 May 2008 3:17:17 PM CST
hi...i would like to add to all the above points discussed above whatever sector v talk about is not self sufficient. when we talk about raising of funds in such sectors...not all companies are in a position to raise money through public....hence, banking sector plays the most imp role here when funds r concerned every industry is dependent on it and vice-versa. in todays scenerio definitely i agree that public or nationalised banks are at a deterioriting stage but not all( eg: SBI, BoB, ) almost all banks have now realised the imp of services marketing and r working on it after facing threat from foriegn banks.one can't expect the most imp resource i.e. capital to be in the private or foreign hands.just for the purpose of growth of individual co's the entire economy cannot be handed over to the private sector.there should be a fair blend of private n public undertaking.
|
|
said this on 09 Aug 2008 11:55:45 AM CST
Well my dear friend if you are talking about the public sector banks then let me tell they have the poorest management including SBI, as an evidence we can look at the growth rate, you will find that the private sector banks are growing at the higher rate then the public sector banks, and the day is not very far when private bank surpass the public sector banks, if they do not wake up now.......it will be very late. Even before some days you must have found the news that SBI is going to recruit 20,000 employees, but let me tell you it is gonna be a flop idea, cause the people they recruiting are either 12th standard passed or graduate only, the new era requires people having business intelligence, and believe me you will find the same thing that i am telling you.
|
|
said this on 23 Feb 2007 3:30:46 AM CST
WELL SIR,YOUR COMMENT ON PRIVATE AS WELL AS ON PUBLIC SECTER IS GOOD ENOUGH BUT IT WILL BE MORE BENEFICIAL IF U ADD SOME DATA MATERIALS.I AM FULLY AGREE WITH UR POINT THAT BEFORE TALKING ABOUT PRIVATIZATION THE VERY FIRST THING WE SHOULD DISCUSS IS THE SECTORS WE ARE GOING TO DEAL WITH.AS OFFCOURSE ALL THE SECTORS CAN'T BE PRIVATIZED AS IT WOULDN'T BE A SAFE DEAL.
|
|
said this on 24 Feb 2007 7:32:53 PM CST
Any topic given in GD is in such a way that anyone can say its good in either way depending on the context.So what I think is its not good to say that privatization or public sector depends on the context. It shows that you are not confident enough to take a decision
|
|
said this on 27 Feb 2007 3:46:06 AM CST
i think a man need a direction for getting success,everbody works hard but it will not produce favourable result until our efforts are well directed towards the target.so this material will help a lot
|
|
said this on 04 Apr 2008 10:20:02 AM CST
dear ankit.. in case study u go with positive and negative both points..so whatever he said is good enough for a GD, as case study is a part of GD
|
|
said this on 10 Mar 2007 2:00:38 PM CST
yes i completly agree with mr.ssrkraju that privtization is not necessary in every sector.can you emagine when railway,airlines,oil componies and electricity will be privatised that time the cost of every thing will be incresed unbelivable and every indians will be suffered more.
|
|
said this on 29 Mar 2007 4:39:24 AM CST
hi
Privtation.....its sound very attractive.bt in India if you privtatise thn you hv to make all ppl employed with good salary.Bt inIndia its tk time or nt going to b hapn.if all public sector b privatise thn autimatically theafting,murder corpuction e.t.c will increase.
n i dont thnk ppl want this.
|
|
said this on 30 Mar 2007 10:26:50 AM CST
It was gud .everyone communicated verywell on the topic but including of some more pts will be beneficial for aspirants.Thanx bye
|
|
said this on 01 Apr 2007 1:31:27 PM CST
Hii, everyone,
as my friend ssrkraju has said can v have private telecom companies n all n all, i would like to inform u Relience is private company recently Mr. Mukesh Ambani has established a petrochemical plant which is the second largest plant in the world.......n nt dat much only he also steped into a vegetable market....u must b aware wid the fact n figures how the price of petrol is increasing
under goverment but Relience petrol pumps are providing petrols on much cheaper rate......Mukesh has said when he wz there in Bang. on opening of vegetable mall there he said...vegetable rates r Fluctuating now a days bt it will not make any difference to this mall...here price will be same in all the situations.... now my point is nowa days private companies r providing much more facilities as compared to govermental
|
|
said this on 08 Apr 2007 11:15:10 PM CST
yes i entirely agree with mr.ssrkraju that privtization is not important in every sector. it is very usefull to freshers when they read it.thankyou
|
|
said this on 23 Apr 2007 4:40:13 AM CST
good one it was helpful
|
|
said this on 26 Apr 2007 10:59:49 PM CST
Good Topic
|
|
said this on 24 Aug 2007 12:36:59 AM CST
i think privatization is very good for our country, coz in private companies employes give their 100%.
|
|
said this on 08 Sep 2007 4:19:05 PM CST
yup! its ok.but not as good as 1st one is. some more posts must be on it.as earier keerthi wrote well, here should b some thing like.. .whatsoever it was ok.
|
|
said this on 13 Sep 2007 2:20:36 PM CST
i am fully agree with Mr. tehzeeb, there should be privatization in public sector,if we talk about the current scenario all the private companies count the value of money and time,while in public sector people are lazy(but they have good knowledge),they dont want to utilize the time and money.
only privatization can change there mindset
if we talk about the poor people,there are lots of hospitals and social organizations which provide help to these people
In crux privatization is the best way for countries growth
|
|
said this on 01 Oct 2007 12:12:14 PM CST
Well friends, I think that selected public sectors should be privatized. The major sectors like railways, oil& natural gas, mining etc. should be kept public. This is because these sectors belong equally to all citizen of India,because they use the natural resources of India, over which every citizen has equal right. Private sectors are primarily driven by profit motive. They may not think of public welfare.
Second thing is that , if all the public sectors are privatized , then we must see that market forces keep the price affordable.We must also ensure that monopoly doesn't occur.
Finally, I think that from economically well settled citizen's point of view,privatization should take place. Because he may get better services. But seeing from poor citizen's point of view, he has public sector services as last ray of hope(e.g. hospitals, education,ration, etc.) Majority of indian population(30-40%) belongs to below poverty line.So, in that way, I think that at present time, not all public sectors should be privatized.
|
|
said this on 03 Oct 2007 12:18:42 AM CST
hello everyone
all u said that's true
but privatisation is necessary but there is some extent
in privatisation many mncs are coming to india and they earn profit for there own
so it is beneficial but up to some extent
|
|
said this on 07 Oct 2007 4:41:48 PM CST
before privatisation of the public sector we should not only consider only few sectors and give decision for the whole . as told telecom in private hands is perfectly all right as we all k now that reliance was the first one to lanch mobiles for rs 500 and call rates 40p all over india , so it depends on sectors
|
|
said this on 08 Oct 2007 3:25:14 AM CST
well i think privitazation is definetly gonna help us in boomin up with the salary system n will improve the standars of living . but we should not forget dat publc sectors are unavoidable .. as one of the person has stated a very valid point about ration card systems. private sectors have a competing tendency n dey move along wid the flow whr as the publis sector is more concerned bopt the nation in whole n has to luk after the very need of all the category of ppl..
|
|
said this on 09 Oct 2007 6:08:21 AM CST
it is good why because we know importance of privatisation through last 5 years development privatization will give effective production then we can get more revenue then automatically the share share of the organization will grow you take simple example government hospital and private hospitals in india the peoples are observe a lot of difference so friend i would like to conclude that privatization of governemtn organization is important
|
|
said this on 09 Oct 2007 6:12:58 AM CST
well the topic is good for discussion but the discussion depends on the different sectors.
|
|
said this on 09 Oct 2007 6:13:12 AM CST
Just remember that three people will not change the fate of India. Also if India looses its public sector to the private players how will the country get money and income from which is used by the low class people in the country.
Then the only thing that is left with India is to increase the tax rates or watch the country in the hands of private players and enjoy the profits which should be in the hands of 'JANTA'.
|
|
said this on 09 Oct 2007 6:14:47 AM CST
many of them saying conversion public sector to private sector some extent it is good but it is not possiable because if each and every compay, organization is privatisied it make trobules to poor people. There are some strategic sectors, which need to be under control of Indian government like oil/gas sector. if this sector is privatisied we will never get the subsidy and this enjoyment never provided by a private sector. The government in this case helps its citizens to a great extent and making them available to its citizens.as like telecom companies in india facing computation because of that we r getting cheply high level products this one is good. take example of hospitals if it is privitized poor people definitely face trobule
|
|
said this on 09 Oct 2007 6:16:21 AM CST
all the public sector companies should not be privatised becoz if all the private companies are set up with a profit motive and 30-40% of people are below poverty line..so the public companies keeps the ethics in mind...take eg of railways,electricity,hospitals for poor if they are privatised..
|
|
said this on 11 Oct 2007 11:25:07 AM CST
Hello,
Hasnt public private partenerships increased over the period of time?
Rajiv Gandhi, the visionary behind opening up economy gave a green signal to private players.
Hitherto, in infrastrucutre alone India has witnessed 86 PPP deals and over $51bn has been poured into the sector. WHat we need is development, and it has to come FAST. Pvt ltd should be approached for exploiting their core competencies and experiences. We dont want 100% privatisition since it would have no regulatory / governing body, which could at times go against public favor as it is happening in case of organised retail where even pvt player are bound to affect a set of community. Imagine the situation where for eg a company like reliance would be free to sel gas all over india without any governance/partnership ? or Sify/hathway dominating broadband space without existence of VSNL which ensure that public intrests are safeguarded?
SO hving pvt players all over would never make a sense especialy in sensitive sectors like defence, DRDO etc..They should be set up where synergies r bounnd to be achieved
|
|
said this on 14 Oct 2007 12:29:53 PM CST
i agree at this point. public sectors should be privitised. in the public sectors 90 persent of the people are sitting idle. in some public sectror companies employees are playing cards. this generation is rapidly moving to the sky. so we think that work hard and get sucess in the work. then only over nation flag is will high and high. so we should work hard. in public sectors there is work but they cant do work since there is no boss and no dead lines if there is a dead lines also they are taking a simple. learning and implimentation is not possible in the public sectors. so in the past days most of the doctors and engineers indians are settle in us and other countries, since here there is no grouth. if it is a privitisation there is a some ristriction. so compulsory work hard. and think, learn some thing, implementing something and achive a new things, so that in the w
|
|
said this on 17 Oct 2007 9:57:27 PM CST
Its true totally public sector is not converted into private sector Bcoz different sector has diffrent pons and cons which different level or category of the people. we don't forget that India is rich but Indian are poor. these poor Indian has go for only in the public sector bcoz there are coming in poverty line. so i can say only that once u get the privatized the sector its increase the economy growth but poverty line people will suffer wch is huge in number....
|
|
said this on 18 Oct 2007 1:00:51 AM CST
it's ok only private sector is providing good services,even public sectors org is providing good services we cann't forget S.B.I bank,ONGC,BSNL ETC.these companies providing beeter facility .
|
|
said this on 18 Oct 2007 2:42:45 PM CST
hi to all,
acc to me privatization of public sector will be very benificial nt only to org but also to the people.
coz as v all know very well the diff bet the service provided by gov hospital and a private hospital ..
there is lot of issues in gov sectors which cant be solved there is no one who is deeply interested in development of gov sector so if they r organised in a better way they will be a boon to the socity otherwise it is better to privatize them
|
|
said this on 20 Oct 2007 1:05:25 AM CST
IT IS VERY WELL SAID THAT DECISIONS LIKE THIS ARE TO BE TAKEN WITH PROPER CONSIDERATION OF THE IMPACT WHICH IT WILL HAVE ON POLITICAL, ECONOMICAL, SOCIAL,TECHNOLOGICAL AND LEGAL ENVIRONMENT OF THE COUNTRY. A INDIAN ECONOMY IS NOT WORKING IN A VACUUM, IT NEEDS THE SUPPORT OF PRIVATE PLAYERS AND THE GOVERNMENT. WE CAN'T UNDERESTIMATE THE ROLE OF GOVERNMENT OR PUBLIC SECTORS AS THEY ARE THE NATION BUILDING FORCES. HOWEVER, WE CAN'T OVERESTIMATE THE ROLE OF PRIVATE SECTORS, AS THEY ARE WORKING JUST FOR PROFITS. NO DOUBT PRIVATE PLAYERS ARE MORE ENERGETIC AND ENTHUSIASTIC ABOUT THEIR SUCESS BUT IT WON'T BE TOO MUCH TO SAY THAT THEY CAN OVERLOOK THE NATION'S CONCERN OVER THERE OWN. SO AT THIS MOMENT WE AS A CITIZEN OF INDIA, HAVE TO SHOW OUR ZEAL TO MAKE OUR COUNTRY A DEVELOPED NATION AS SOON AS POSSIBLE BY EXPLOATING ALL THE OPPORTUNITIES WEATHER IT IS BY PRIVATISING SOME OF OUR KEY SECTORS.
|
|
said this on 31 Oct 2007 12:37:23 AM CST
All the private sector should be privatised
|
|
said this on 05 Nov 2007 8:53:00 AM CST
this topic is very nice and all d ppl gave very good conclusions...
|
|
said this on 05 Nov 2007 12:10:22 PM CST
well i think we need to look into the competencies of both public n private sectors..
public sectors are designed to serve all the citizens may it poor middle class or upper class...
private sectors wherein promise a higher standard service...
i think we need to motivate the public sector to improvise the way they are functioning...so that it will help in overall development of the nation.
instead of commenting and creating the perception that public sectors(SARKARI) are not a serious affair .. we need to create awareness and encourage the public run institutions to perform better.
so its not necessary that we have to privatise all the public institutions(sectors)
|
|
said this on 18 Nov 2007 9:49:44 AM CST
thanx for provinding this kind of stuff. i m sure this is going to help me a lot and i can also get massive knowladge out of it.
thanx once again
|
|
said this on 21 Nov 2007 10:36:08 AM CST
Yes I appreciate most of the comments,I agree on this that Depending upon the sectors private and public identity can be given,One thing for the sure when we talk of privatization its the best in Todays scenario thereby leading to growth of world economy, meeting the standard of life of people of India,why we people are poor due to un employment, which private companies are providing nowin comparison to public enterprises,To quote an example,
Be it Reliance, Bharti , or aditya Birla Group,with the onset of retail merchandising, things will be improved further, thereby decreasing the costs leading to price wars waiving the involvement of middleman(real earners) and providing everything under one roof,so anyways coming up of Reliance retails, Pharma, Walmart is beneficial for the development of or country keeping in prespective the development of mankind
Thanks to share with you all
|
|
said this on 27 Nov 2007 6:42:49 AM CST
well i think we need to look into the competencies of both public n private sectors.. public sectors are designed to serve all the citizens may it poor middle class or upper class... private sectors wherein promise a higher standard service... i think we need to motivate the public sector to improvise the way they are functioning...so that it will help in overall development of the nation. instead of commenting and creating the perception that public sectors(SARKARI) are not a serious affair .. we need to create awareness and encourage the public run institutions to perform better
|
|
said this on 04 Dec 2007 5:07:01 AM CST
yes my friends has told very valid points
then wat is the need of LPG
If itis privitized there will be Value for every thing (money ,time,eforts )
One more thing i would like share with u friends
"SOMEBODY CANT DO EVERYTHING
BUT EVERYBODY CAN DO SOMETHING"
So we will together(govt &private) can enjoy taste of the success.
thanq for giving me this oppurtunity to share my feelings with
thanq
bye
|
|
said this on 06 Dec 2007 1:56:35 AM CST
Acc,raju there r few sectors which should not be privitised but even govt is taking necessary steps to give its best service.the attitude/feeling of people on public sectors should change for example hospitals private hospitals cannot reach to rural villages,and govt is inviting private
sectors to serve people for better service.Any how we have a right to use public sectors (ex:rtc)under certain offers (ex:student pass)which cannot be given by the private sector at all.So it is a responsibility of a citizen to use public sectors and take part in the development of the organisation
|
Author)