Government Jobs Interview Questions
Replies:
Yes of course privatization of public sectors leads to some healthy changes in an org. b's when you take public sectors u can find some slackness (or a little bit) delay in their services. But in case of private since service is there first and foremost duty they act rapidly.
Hi All,
Privatization of public sector. Lot depends of which sector we are talking about. Let me clarify few doubts in the primary stage. Can we expect all private hospitals in our cities in our town which do not have an entry for poor people, can we have only private sector telephone companies, can we have private companies have complete control on oil reserves, can we have all transport be provided by private sector and RTC vanishes, can we expect an private sector to take care of our defense. In the same way we cant expect the government to set up an IT industry on its own, we cant expect them to handle all the load of flight transport. My point over here is both are not mutually exclusive. We need to accept the fact that both are here to stay and we cannot make it without one. They do have their importance and we need to deal this issue according to the context.
There are some strategic sectors, which need to be under control of Indian government like oil/gas sector. The subsidy we enjoy will be never provided by a private sector. The government in this case helps its citizens to a great extent and making them available to its citizens. The ration card system is a great boon to the poor. Coming to some sectors like steel and mobile where both are present and a healthy competition among them always benefits the customers. It is also a point to be noted that Government itself cannot take the complete load just like it cant take the load of all flight customers where private sector is playing its helping role. Then there is education sector, which also has good competition with CBSE matching with any education system of either state syllabus or the schools coming up with their own syllabus. The public transport sector too is a mix of public and private and here you can see a striking difference. You can easily differentiate the profit motive of private personal whose salaries depend on the profit to their owner. In autos you can see some 6-8 people are dumped then starts the engine. I do accept that some services are best in private sector as they fear their job loss and their owners do get the best out of them by making them to work more no. Of hours.
The lazy mindset of some public sector could be taken into account to convert it to a private sector. I would like to suggest that counseling sessions for these to have a better future by working for the organization would help it to grow better and be under the public sector umbrella. We can take some examples by some of our previous strategies, which helped us to renovate dull companies, which lacked in performance. If a private individual is going to buy the company and could change its fortunes, why can't the public government do it? It can. Running away from a trouble is not a solution. Facing it head-on will produce better results.
I totally agree with Mr.ssrkraju.... As he said it depends on which sector we are talking about. And both have a different importance of their own. Privatization has its own proms and public sector have their own. I think both needs to be there as far today’s development is concerned.
Taking the view it is right that the work at public sectors is not working the way it should. But if everyone understands the responsibilities then it can also work the same way as private sectors. Again I think for some sectors it is ok otherwise it should be done by the respected ones itself...
POST YOUR VIEWS ON THIS TOPIC ......
|
said this on 09 Aug 2008 11:37:17 AM IST
Well friends, as we all know that most of the government units are known for their poor service level, that is why the private organisations are came in picture and even making huge profits out of the same customer base. The basic reason behind is the level of understanding, it means the junior level, middle level and the senior level management are not as much sharp or I should say not as professional as the private sector's all the level of management. Even the environment of the organisation is also matters.
By this point i just want to say that at each level of an organisation there should be an educated and highly professional person needs to be there. If we look at the features responsible for the success of private organisations we came to know that they at every level of management you will find a highly qualified and professional manager, and they set-up all the problems at their own level, so it is nothing but the power dilution and even the highest authority is wholly responsible for all the actions taken at every level of management.
|
|
said this on 27 Apr 2010 6:09:33 AM IST
Yea i agree with you,but if we take case of india..80% of the population is rural so they will be able to afford to get operated in private hospitals.We need to improve our public service facilities and all that is needed is govt. to take a step forword so that we can expect better in future.So lots of pts needs to be considered before privatising market.
|
|
said this on 14 May 2010 11:21:02 AM IST
this is the fact in rural area.people cant afford to pay
|
|
said this on 26 Aug 2010 7:03:19 PM IST
hello friends,
In my opinion,its depend on which sector to be privatised.Because if we talk about private hospitals a poor or a middle person cannot afford their medical services.But its true that good quality of services are provided by private sectors as compared to pubkic sector. Even some people who are working in public sector use rough language to the customers which is very bad.And in private sectors customers are treated in a very good manner and grievances are handled in quickly also.
|
|
said this on 23 Jan 2007 7:40:31 PM IST
Well friends, privtation is a very contentious issue. Just take the example of Private Hospitals, ther poor cant even think of getting a treatment there and if we do make all hospitals private then I can for sure say the people will die for treatment. And about the Power Industry, if its privatised, we are sure to get proper power supply but with increased rate per unit. The people of India made a huge hue and cry about the increasing petrol price and if the electricty rate are increased then look at the reaction.
|
|
said this on 20 Jan 2010 9:59:47 PM IST
well i totally agree with what dinesh said...its not about getting anything privatised...but its about how to deal with with the public sector enterprises.
It is always benificial to have private sector units in a country but as we are still a progressing nation where still more than 30% of the population is below poverty line,will it be ethical to think just of profit.I think it will not be fair enough for the people who can not afford to pay for it.
public sector units shall not be privatised only what needs to be checked out is management.
|
|
said this on 09 Mar 2010 7:03:18 PM IST
well said mayank
|
|
said this on 13 Apr 2010 6:11:20 PM IST
I am not agreed on this piont completely Government sector is known for its red tapism and corruption.Dealing withthe govt. officers will definately bind you to go door to door.but on the other side , private sector is dignified for its efficient managment and for making the best use of resources. for aspiring to be a devloped country , there is neeed for having a effective managment strategy as we have a sufficient means and human resources like any developed nation but need to make best use of it. In every budget , a large sum of money is alloted to government department but because of dormant and unoptimistic attitute of people , there is a very little impact on our economy.so if we can transformed this scenrio by aillance with private sector and if we have to pay a liitle a bit more for this then it does not matter.
|
|
said this on 17 Aug 2010 2:27:56 PM IST
Well said pooja ,I agree with you what you have said ,but one thing I want to clear that private sector make all the things easier ,at the cost of what ? the answer is money ,at present scenario 70% people live in villages and they are not capable enough to spend huge money.suppose Train ,Hospitals,schools,colleges all become private then where these 70% people will go.By making all the sector private we just separating the India into two group i.e rich group and poor group .The thing is that India is still developing country.All we will need to do is that we have to stay unified and support Government to provide us best facilities .who make the Government definitely we ,then we have to faith on it.Once we allow to breed the private sector in full swing then we are completely in clutch of them and our freedom are lost.On the other hand I am not totally disagree that private sector is bad.The thing is that we need to have better administrator who have capability to manage the resource properly.
|
|
said this on 03 Sep 2010 1:54:26 PM IST
Well said pooja ,but we can not privatize all the sectors for getting the best outcome because we have to take the decisions which are helping to the people of India .Then only our developing India will become developed one.I feel the better solution is we have to appoint a some Intelligent private committee for checking the working of Govt sector.Based on those results we will take appropriate actions.By coming to Hospt sector we have to give some rankings the Hospitals.Then there is healthy competition in Hospitals like IITs in Indian Educational System.
|
|
said this on 13 Apr 2010 6:15:06 PM IST
I am agreed on this piont completely Government sector is known for its red tapism and corruption.Dealing withthe govt. officers will definately bind you to go door to door.but on the other side , private sector is dignified for its efficient managment and for making the best use of resources. for aspiring to be a devloped country , there is neeed for having a effective managment strategy as we have a sufficient means and human resources like any developed nation but need to make best use of it. In every budget , a large sum of money is alloted to government department but because of dormant and unoptimistic attitute of people , there is a very little impact on our economy.so if we can transformed this scenrio by aillance with private sector and if we have to pay a liitle a bit more for this then it does not matter.
|
|
said this on 14 May 2010 11:26:18 AM IST
actually the current situation is meangfully describe by pooja.
|
|
said this on 05 Jul 2010 7:41:50 PM IST
i am totaly agree with this statement.
but it should be done on sansad.
|
|
said this on 01 Jul 2010 8:16:21 AM IST
i agree with mayank......
|
|
said this on 02 May 2010 8:37:58 PM IST
i agree with u very nice ..
|
|
said this on 02 May 2010 8:46:37 PM IST
i agree with dinesh if there is priatisation is done then there only loss of those peoples who r not able to pay.i thought that it's not right.
|
|
said this on 15 Jun 2010 4:01:24 PM IST
hi.. Friends.
i totally agree with the comment given by the dinesh..
if privatization is done in every sector then this will really going to create big problem as normal or the poor people can't survive in private sector..
n this will lead to change in the govt..and again the election will be conducted which result in the missuses of the fund deposited n the fraud politician can again fill their pocket n enjoy the situation..
so again here the poor people will become the target n they hv to face the problem..
so ,i think in our country its time to keep both the sectors working mutually in order to balance the situation n condition..
|
|
said this on 28 Jan 2007 3:56:27 AM IST
i agree that public sector should be privatised..in private sector all things are handled more efficiently and effectively..more money is earned in case of private setor..hence we can hope to increase our salary i.e. average salary of the country will markedly
increase..which we can say to an extent that our country will develop at a faster rate..hospitals if privatised will result in better medical care..even if it is perceived as more costly as compared to govt. sectors..then let me give you an overview of things which are managed in hospitals...a patient if is poor is not dealt with utmost care and attention..is treated like a lowly thing...but had the patient been well off or had ministerial contacts then he will be given full care with all possible facilities..then wat is the use of public sector handling various institutions????
|
|
said this on 12 Mar 2010 1:38:22 AM IST
no i think that public company should not be privatised because in public company there is mostly provisions for poor people but in private no relationship with poor.and in private sector company all the money are gathered at a place bt in public sector its spread among the public.
our india is poor country so first we think about to remove the poverty of our country before anything.
|
|
said this on 17 Jul 2010 10:08:24 PM IST
i m fully agree with u n wants to add tht privatisation also increase employment ,working efficiency....
|
|
said this on 11 Feb 2007 8:10:35 PM IST
sir ur info is excellent.but i advice u to put the keypoints as first.bcaz if we want to search it takes too much of time.so plz give key with as possible as short.
thanks for give us this info
bye
|
|
said this on 12 Feb 2007 11:30:19 PM IST
IT WILL BE USEFUL IF SOME MORE POINTS ARE DISCUSSED UNDER THIS TOPIC
|
|
said this on 10 May 2008 3:17:17 PM IST
hi...i would like to add to all the above points discussed above whatever sector v talk about is not self sufficient. when we talk about raising of funds in such sectors...not all companies are in a position to raise money through public....hence, banking sector plays the most imp role here when funds r concerned every industry is dependent on it and vice-versa. in todays scenerio definitely i agree that public or nationalised banks are at a deterioriting stage but not all( eg: SBI, BoB, ) almost all banks have now realised the imp of services marketing and r working on it after facing threat from foriegn banks.one can't expect the most imp resource i.e. capital to be in the private or foreign hands.just for the purpose of growth of individual co's the entire economy cannot be handed over to the private sector.there should be a fair blend of private n public undertaking.
|
|
said this on 09 Aug 2008 11:55:45 AM IST
Well my dear friend if you are talking about the public sector banks then let me tell they have the poorest management including SBI, as an evidence we can look at the growth rate, you will find that the private sector banks are growing at the higher rate then the public sector banks, and the day is not very far when private bank surpass the public sector banks, if they do not wake up now.......it will be very late. Even before some days you must have found the news that SBI is going to recruit 20,000 employees, but let me tell you it is gonna be a flop idea, cause the people they recruiting are either 12th standard passed or graduate only, the new era requires people having business intelligence, and believe me you will find the same thing that i am telling you.
|
|
said this on 17 Mar 2010 11:05:57 PM IST
yes, my dear friend you are right and i agreed with your views..today we need private sectors so much because there are more efficient people are worked with more efficiency like SBI well now the recuirtement seat is grower and be 25000..and everyone 12th passed individual can feel this form..so this is not so much good for public sectors and we should need private sectors..
|
|
said this on 23 Feb 2007 3:30:46 AM IST
WELL SIR,YOUR COMMENT ON PRIVATE AS WELL AS ON PUBLIC SECTER IS GOOD ENOUGH BUT IT WILL BE MORE BENEFICIAL IF U ADD SOME DATA MATERIALS.I AM FULLY AGREE WITH UR POINT THAT BEFORE TALKING ABOUT PRIVATIZATION THE VERY FIRST THING WE SHOULD DISCUSS IS THE SECTORS WE ARE GOING TO DEAL WITH.AS OFFCOURSE ALL THE SECTORS CAN'T BE PRIVATIZED AS IT WOULDN'T BE A SAFE DEAL.
|
|
said this on 24 Feb 2007 7:32:53 PM IST
Any topic given in GD is in such a way that anyone can say its good in either way depending on the context.So what I think is its not good to say that privatization or public sector depends on the context. It shows that you are not confident enough to take a decision
|
|
said this on 27 Feb 2007 3:46:06 AM IST
i think a man need a direction for getting success,everbody works hard but it will not produce favourable result until our efforts are well directed towards the target.so this material will help a lot
|
|
said this on 04 Apr 2008 10:20:02 AM IST
dear ankit.. in case study u go with positive and negative both points..so whatever he said is good enough for a GD, as case study is a part of GD
|
|
said this on 10 Mar 2007 2:00:38 PM IST
yes i completly agree with mr.ssrkraju that privtization is not necessary in every sector.can you emagine when railway,airlines,oil componies and electricity will be privatised that time the cost of every thing will be incresed unbelivable and every indians will be suffered more.
|
|
said this on 29 Mar 2007 4:39:24 AM IST
hi
Privtation.....its sound very attractive.bt in India if you privtatise thn you hv to make all ppl employed with good salary.Bt inIndia its tk time or nt going to b hapn.if all public sector b privatise thn autimatically theafting,murder corpuction e.t.c will increase.
n i dont thnk ppl want this.
|
|
said this on 30 Mar 2007 10:26:50 AM IST
It was gud .everyone communicated verywell on the topic but including of some more pts will be beneficial for aspirants.Thanx bye
|
|
said this on 01 Apr 2007 1:31:27 PM IST
Hii, everyone,
as my friend ssrkraju has said can v have private telecom companies n all n all, i would like to inform u Relience is private company recently Mr. Mukesh Ambani has established a petrochemical plant which is the second largest plant in the world.......n nt dat much only he also steped into a vegetable market....u must b aware wid the fact n figures how the price of petrol is increasing
under goverment but Relience petrol pumps are providing petrols on much cheaper rate......Mukesh has said when he wz there in Bang. on opening of vegetable mall there he said...vegetable rates r Fluctuating now a days bt it will not make any difference to this mall...here price will be same in all the situations.... now my point is nowa days private companies r providing much more facilities as compared to govermental
|
|
said this on 08 Apr 2007 11:15:10 PM IST
yes i entirely agree with mr.ssrkraju that privtization is not important in every sector. it is very usefull to freshers when they read it.thankyou
|
|
said this on 23 Apr 2007 4:40:13 AM IST
good one it was helpful
|
|
said this on 26 Apr 2007 10:59:49 PM IST
Good Topic
|
|
said this on 24 Aug 2007 12:36:59 AM IST
i think privatization is very good for our country, coz in private companies employes give their 100%.
|
|
said this on 18 Sep 2009 2:40:07 PM IST
i strongly agree with mridul jain but every sector should not be privatized. some sectors which should require the devolopment they should be privatized
|
|
said this on 20 Jan 2010 10:17:00 PM IST
well mridul i would like to make a remark on your comment that in private companies the employees give their 100% for sure...but rather than giving 100%,more than 100% of them is taken out at the cost of handful of salary.Needless to say employees over there are made to be worked for more than 12 hours a day to achive their goal for the day.this is givin terrible consequences..divorces hav increased as couples are not able to spend time with each other under sever work pressure.Many new diseases have came into existence..all these consequences themselves say the story no need to comment that public sector is the favourite.
|
|
said this on 16 May 2010 11:45:02 PM IST
Well mayank i do agree with wat u said........ its true that privatisation may give good outputs n dat would b fast enough but not now....i mean v r still a developing nation...majority of d peple r poor n they do rely on public sectors for their needs....i think tat both of these sectors r equally important....they r both strong enough to improve the current position of India...the only need is that they work properly,take gud decisions on behalf of the company,the peple of India as well as on behalf of the nation inorder to make it another developed nation on the globe............
|
|
said this on 08 Sep 2007 4:19:05 PM IST
yup! its ok.but not as good as 1st one is. some more posts must be on it.as earier keerthi wrote well, here should b some thing like.. .whatsoever it was ok.
|
|
said this on 13 Sep 2007 2:20:36 PM IST
i am fully agree with Mr. tehzeeb, there should be privatization in public sector,if we talk about the current scenario all the private companies count the value of money and time,while in public sector people are lazy(but they have good knowledge),they dont want to utilize the time and money.
only privatization can change there mindset
if we talk about the poor people,there are lots of hospitals and social organizations which provide help to these people
In crux privatization is the best way for countries growth
|
|
said this on 01 Oct 2007 12:12:14 PM IST
Well friends, I think that selected public sectors should be privatized. The major sectors like railways, oil& natural gas, mining etc. should be kept public. This is because these sectors belong equally to all citizen of India,because they use the natural resources of India, over which every citizen has equal right. Private sectors are primarily driven by profit motive. They may not think of public welfare.
Second thing is that , if all the public sectors are privatized , then we must see that market forces keep the price affordable.We must also ensure that monopoly doesn't occur.
Finally, I think that from economically well settled citizen's point of view,privatization should take place. Because he may get better services. But seeing from poor citizen's point of view, he has public sector services as last ray of hope(e.g. hospitals, education,ration, etc.) Majority of indian population(30-40%) belongs to below poverty line.So, in that way, I think that at present time, not all public sectors should be privatized.
|
|
said this on 03 Oct 2007 12:18:42 AM IST
hello everyone
all u said that's true
but privatisation is necessary but there is some extent
in privatisation many mncs are coming to india and they earn profit for there own
so it is beneficial but up to some extent
|
|
said this on 07 Oct 2007 4:41:48 PM IST
before privatisation of the public sector we should not only consider only few sectors and give decision for the whole . as told telecom in private hands is perfectly all right as we all k now that reliance was the first one to lanch mobiles for rs 500 and call rates 40p all over india , so it depends on sectors
|
|
said this on 08 Oct 2007 3:25:14 AM IST
well i think privitazation is definetly gonna help us in boomin up with the salary system n will improve the standars of living . but we should not forget dat publc sectors are unavoidable .. as one of the person has stated a very valid point about ration card systems. private sectors have a competing tendency n dey move along wid the flow whr as the publis sector is more concerned bopt the nation in whole n has to luk after the very need of all the category of ppl..
|
|
said this on 09 Oct 2007 6:08:21 AM IST
it is good why because we know importance of privatisation through last 5 years development privatization will give effective production then we can get more revenue then automatically the share share of the organization will grow you take simple example government hospital and private hospitals in india the peoples are observe a lot of difference so friend i would like to conclude that privatization of governemtn organization is important
|
|
said this on 09 Oct 2007 6:12:58 AM IST
well the topic is good for discussion but the discussion depends on the different sectors.
|
|
said this on 09 Oct 2007 6:13:12 AM IST
Just remember that three people will not change the fate of India. Also if India looses its public sector to the private players how will the country get money and income from which is used by the low class people in the country.
Then the only thing that is left with India is to increase the tax rates or watch the country in the hands of private players and enjoy the profits which should be in the hands of 'JANTA'.
|
|
said this on 09 Oct 2007 6:14:47 AM IST
many of them saying conversion public sector to private sector some extent it is good but it is not possiable because if each and every compay, organization is privatisied it make trobules to poor people. There are some strategic sectors, which need to be under control of Indian government like oil/gas sector. if this sector is privatisied we will never get the subsidy and this enjoyment never provided by a private sector. The government in this case helps its citizens to a great extent and making them available to its citizens.as like telecom companies in india facing computation because of that we r getting cheply high level products this one is good. take example of hospitals if it is privitized poor people definitely face trobule
|
|
said this on 09 Oct 2007 6:16:21 AM IST
all the public sector companies should not be privatised becoz if all the private companies are set up with a profit motive and 30-40% of people are below poverty line..so the public companies keeps the ethics in mind...take eg of railways,electricity,hospitals for poor if they are privatised..
|
|
said this on 11 Oct 2007 11:25:07 AM IST
Hello,
Hasnt public private partenerships increased over the period of time?
Rajiv Gandhi, the visionary behind opening up economy gave a green signal to private players.
Hitherto, in infrastrucutre alone India has witnessed 86 PPP deals and over $51bn has been poured into the sector. WHat we need is development, and it has to come FAST. Pvt ltd should be approached for exploiting their core competencies and experiences. We dont want 100% privatisition since it would have no regulatory / governing body, which could at times go against public favor as it is happening in case of organised retail where even pvt player are bound to affect a set of community. Imagine the situation where for eg a company like reliance would be free to sel gas all over india without any governance/partnership ? or Sify/hathway dominating broadband space without existence of VSNL which ensure that public intrests are safeguarded?
SO hving pvt players all over would never make a sense especialy in sensitive sectors like defence, DRDO etc..They should be set up where synergies r bounnd to be achieved
|
|
said this on 14 Oct 2007 12:29:53 PM IST
i agree at this point. public sectors should be privitised. in the public sectors 90 persent of the people are sitting idle. in some public sectror companies employees are playing cards. this generation is rapidly moving to the sky. so we think that work hard and get sucess in the work. then only over nation flag is will high and high. so we should work hard. in public sectors there is work but they cant do work since there is no boss and no dead lines if there is a dead lines also they are taking a simple. learning and implimentation is not possible in the public sectors. so in the past days most of the doctors and engineers indians are settle in us and other countries, since here there is no grouth. if it is a privitisation there is a some ristriction. so compulsory work hard. and think, learn some thing, implementing something and achive a new things, so that in the w
|
|
said this on 17 Oct 2007 9:57:27 PM IST
Its true totally public sector is not converted into private sector Bcoz different sector has diffrent pons and cons which different level or category of the people. we don't forget that India is rich but Indian are poor. these poor Indian has go for only in the public sector bcoz there are coming in poverty line. so i can say only that once u get the privatized the sector its increase the economy growth but poverty line people will suffer wch is huge in number....
|
|
said this on 18 Oct 2007 1:00:51 AM IST
it's ok only private sector is providing good services,even public sectors org is providing good services we cann't forget S.B.I bank,ONGC,BSNL ETC.these companies providing beeter facility .
|
|
said this on 18 Oct 2007 2:42:45 PM IST
hi to all,
acc to me privatization of public sector will be very benificial nt only to org but also to the people.
coz as v all know very well the diff bet the service provided by gov hospital and a private hospital ..
there is lot of issues in gov sectors which cant be solved there is no one who is deeply interested in development of gov sector so if they r organised in a better way they will be a boon to the socity otherwise it is better to privatize them
|
|
said this on 20 Oct 2007 1:05:25 AM IST
IT IS VERY WELL SAID THAT DECISIONS LIKE THIS ARE TO BE TAKEN WITH PROPER CONSIDERATION OF THE IMPACT WHICH IT WILL HAVE ON POLITICAL, ECONOMICAL, SOCIAL,TECHNOLOGICAL AND LEGAL ENVIRONMENT OF THE COUNTRY. A INDIAN ECONOMY IS NOT WORKING IN A VACUUM, IT NEEDS THE SUPPORT OF PRIVATE PLAYERS AND THE GOVERNMENT. WE CAN'T UNDERESTIMATE THE ROLE OF GOVERNMENT OR PUBLIC SECTORS AS THEY ARE THE NATION BUILDING FORCES. HOWEVER, WE CAN'T OVERESTIMATE THE ROLE OF PRIVATE SECTORS, AS THEY ARE WORKING JUST FOR PROFITS. NO DOUBT PRIVATE PLAYERS ARE MORE ENERGETIC AND ENTHUSIASTIC ABOUT THEIR SUCESS BUT IT WON'T BE TOO MUCH TO SAY THAT THEY CAN OVERLOOK THE NATION'S CONCERN OVER THERE OWN. SO AT THIS MOMENT WE AS A CITIZEN OF INDIA, HAVE TO SHOW OUR ZEAL TO MAKE OUR COUNTRY A DEVELOPED NATION AS SOON AS POSSIBLE BY EXPLOATING ALL THE OPPORTUNITIES WEATHER IT IS BY PRIVATISING SOME OF OUR KEY SECTORS.
|
|
said this on 31 Oct 2007 12:37:23 AM IST
All the private sector should be privatised
|
|
said this on 05 Nov 2007 8:53:00 AM IST
this topic is very nice and all d ppl gave very good conclusions...
|
|
said this on 05 Nov 2007 12:10:22 PM IST
well i think we need to look into the competencies of both public n private sectors..
public sectors are designed to serve all the citizens may it poor middle class or upper class...
private sectors wherein promise a higher standard service...
i think we need to motivate the public sector to improvise the way they are functioning...so that it will help in overall development of the nation.
instead of commenting and creating the perception that public sectors(SARKARI) are not a serious affair .. we need to create awareness and encourage the public run institutions to perform better.
so its not necessary that we have to privatise all the public institutions(sectors)
|
|
said this on 18 Nov 2007 9:49:44 AM IST
thanx for provinding this kind of stuff. i m sure this is going to help me a lot and i can also get massive knowladge out of it.
thanx once again
|
|
said this on 21 Nov 2007 10:36:08 AM IST
Yes I appreciate most of the comments,I agree on this that Depending upon the sectors private and public identity can be given,One thing for the sure when we talk of privatization its the best in Todays scenario thereby leading to growth of world economy, meeting the standard of life of people of India,why we people are poor due to un employment, which private companies are providing nowin comparison to public enterprises,To quote an example,
Be it Reliance, Bharti , or aditya Birla Group,with the onset of retail merchandising, things will be improved further, thereby decreasing the costs leading to price wars waiving the involvement of middleman(real earners) and providing everything under one roof,so anyways coming up of Reliance retails, Pharma, Walmart is beneficial for the development of or country keeping in prespective the development of mankind
Thanks to share with you all
|
|
said this on 27 Nov 2007 6:42:49 AM IST
well i think we need to look into the competencies of both public n private sectors.. public sectors are designed to serve all the citizens may it poor middle class or upper class... private sectors wherein promise a higher standard service... i think we need to motivate the public sector to improvise the way they are functioning...so that it will help in overall development of the nation. instead of commenting and creating the perception that public sectors(SARKARI) are not a serious affair .. we need to create awareness and encourage the public run institutions to perform better
|
|
said this on 04 Dec 2007 5:07:01 AM IST
yes my friends has told very valid points
then wat is the need of LPG
If itis privitized there will be Value for every thing (money ,time,eforts )
One more thing i would like share with u friends
"SOMEBODY CANT DO EVERYTHING
BUT EVERYBODY CAN DO SOMETHING"
So we will together(govt &private) can enjoy taste of the success.
thanq for giving me this oppurtunity to share my feelings with
thanq
bye
|
|
said this on 06 Dec 2007 1:56:35 AM IST
Acc,raju there r few sectors which should not be privitised but even govt is taking necessary steps to give its best service.the attitude/feeling of people on public sectors should change for example hospitals private hospitals cannot reach to rural villages,and govt is inviting private
sectors to serve people for better service.Any how we have a right to use public sectors (ex:rtc)under certain offers (ex:student pass)which cannot be given by the private sector at all.So it is a responsibility of a citizen to use public sectors and take part in the development of the organisation
|
|
said this on 06 Dec 2007 1:56:36 AM IST
Acc,raju there r few sectors which should not be privitised but even govt is taking necessary steps to give its best service.the attitude/feeling of people on public sectors should change for example hospitals private hospitals cannot reach to rural villages,and govt is inviting private
sectors to serve people for better service.Any how we have a right to use public sectors (ex:rtc)under certain offers (ex:student pass)which cannot be given by the private sector at all.So it is a responsibility of a citizen to use public sectors and take part in the development of the organisation
|
|
said this on 14 Dec 2007 8:45:20 AM IST
Hi everyone,i say that eventhough there is both gov. and priv. sectors both r running for us with some benefits and with some difficults but anyway gov. buses r providing free pass for students,but which the priv. sectors not do so...........
|
|
said this on 29 Dec 2007 4:18:12 AM IST
both private and publice sector is two side of coin. country can not think development to left any one sector. both are neccessary u cant say all public sector should be privatised if it is happen than govt. lost his power.first we have to know for which sector we have talking about like we can not give defence and railways to private sector because they are more in profit making rather than serving to peoples but sick unit of public sector which goes in losses we privatise them.
|
|
said this on 30 Dec 2007 3:31:42 PM IST
I think, all of the articles have been good from discussion point of view.
What I feel is, making a public sector privatized has different different things to be considered. It has some good as well as bad depending on the type of industry you are going to make private.
If you look at oil services and LPG gas services, if they will be privatized it will be too costly for a middleman to bear the burden of these without subsidies provided by the govt. Presence of a govt company into the market also controls the prices and regulates the market. Basic facilities like water and electricity are the ones which are good only when in hand of government because govt is not going to think about profit only. It will also think about the future of that and will provide subsidies if needed.
But the other services like telecom services, automobile services and IT services are good in hand of private sector firm because they will compete in this field and even they will have to keep their prices low at the same time as they are not the basic needs of a person because if prices are too high, a middle man can cut down the consumption of these services. The only way to come ahead will be quality and low cost so public sector except the sector for basic requirements of the country should be privatized which will result in far better situation of country.
Let me take an example if all the hospitals are being privatized, will every person of India be able to get the health care services? Will he be able to survive in this situation?
So there is no point in sectors related to basic services being privatized.
|
|
said this on 05 Jan 2008 3:14:41 AM IST
the points placed by everyone is correct acc to them. i to agree with most of my frens that not all but some public sectors which needs help from private sectors,whici are not efficient enough to serve the public should be given in the hands of private comp so that the services provided to public are improved.....
|
|
said this on 09 Jan 2008 6:31:54 AM IST
i favour and also disfavour this comment,when we are talking of services in less cost or subsidies then public sector should be followed.But in case of development like in field of IT,Industries,exports and imports private sector to be followed.We require both types of services keeping in mind that both not only help people but our country development also....
|
|
said this on 09 Jan 2008 8:22:31 AM IST
i disfavour the comment. if all the private sector is privatized , the average salary of the people should be increased. our country will developed soon. i accept it, but only 30% of the peoples in india is enjoying the previlage, the remaining 70% are under the poverty line due to the rise in the cost of living.
|
|
said this on 18 Jan 2008 10:38:00 AM IST
Yes ,i agree that public sector should be privatised. But some areas of bsiness shouldn't be becoz about 40% of population in India is below poverty line and they could not afford costly things
|
|
said this on 23 Jan 2008 8:48:32 AM IST
it ws realy good. i got n excellent idea on the topic because i didnt hd ne idea. i came to knw abt many things abt both private n public sectors. thank u.
|
|
said this on 23 Jan 2008 11:53:07 AM IST
its very fine discussion.
|
|
said this on 24 Jan 2008 12:49:20 PM IST
nice discussions ,facts are less is the only weakness..
|
|
said this on 28 Jan 2008 5:54:29 AM IST
acc to me some of the sectors should be kept public ,,bcoz there are some sectors which directly influence poor peoples or those which r below poverty line ,,if these sectors are privatise they effect them ,,bcoz in private sectors they there main objective is to make profit for them then think of others ,,so acc to me some sectors shuld be reserved as semi private
|
|
said this on 29 Jan 2008 5:49:43 AM IST
public sectiors organisation have a mission not only run profitably but also to work for the development of people and social cause. if the public sector like hospital and school college will be privatised then it will be difficult for most of the common people and specially poor people to afford the cost of treatment in the hospital and afford the fees of the education.
|
|
said this on 31 Jan 2008 8:04:34 AM IST
IT IS VERY NICE THANKS FOR GIVING THIS INFORMATION
|
|
said this on 31 Jan 2008 1:07:28 PM IST
its been excellent this site is really excedingly helpful.
|
|
said this on 03 Feb 2008 8:47:27 AM IST
it's a nice topic and is excellent in the above discussions
|
|
said this on 10 Feb 2008 12:51:09 AM IST
it was avery fine article and i got tremendous information..like some of my frenz here,even i think dat all sectors should not be privatised.apart from profits,welfare of people should also be kept in concern.dere r many better services provided by public sector also like sbi,vijaya etc.public and private sector go hand in hand...growth of country can be done by joint effort only.....
|
|
said this on 11 Feb 2008 7:04:51 AM IST
privetization is benifisial for those organisations those not performing well. whr people do not understand there responsiblities...
|
|
said this on 15 Feb 2008 4:39:56 AM IST
ya this is very nice
|
|
said this on 19 Feb 2008 10:06:15 AM IST
hey these points are really very helpful....it gave me 2 think in various prospects....thanks
|
|
said this on 21 Feb 2008 11:53:38 PM IST
I think that those departments from where the govt is earning money i.e. electricity board, incomtax dept., water supply department, should privateized. b'coz in these depatments employes take bribes and the ppl' bear. they mak the false charges against the general ppl' and tak money from them. so that these departments are the root cause of corouption.
|
|
said this on 29 Jul 2008 10:51:43 AM IST
i dont think so if people r payed better then why will they take bribe just bcoz of some people we cannot blame the whole institution i think the govt is doing a fairly good job
|
|
said this on 11 Mar 2008 8:02:56 AM IST
India is a devloping country and most of the people here are very poor if all the public sectors are privetized then where these poor people vl go.complete privetization is possible only in devloped coutries where people are rich enough to afford.its true that their is a all of corouption in the public sector and people do sit idle as my frd gaurav said bt ths is not the only solution for the problem.time has come we should understand our responsibility towards our work.the minset of people must be changed.
|
|
said this on 18 Jun 2008 2:13:41 AM IST
Mr.ssrkraju...u said it well...there are some pints like privetization is definitely help full but not to the extent of all public sector. as u already mentioned...about few sectors...another important sector is railway...if railway is privatized completely it will definitely hit india badly though few thing in rail ways are already in private hand but...the main control is still under govt: and all over the world no where it is successful by the private player such a great extent...
|
|
said this on 25 Aug 2008 11:31:59 AM IST
hi friends,we should encourage the public sectors cos they r the backbone of india,if we take the private sectors, they r working for improvement of that particular company only,they wont bother about the development of the nation.take birla group of companies they r concentrating only to develop their branches allover the world.private players r concerned with the profit only.but the public sectors supports the people who r all below the poverty line,thank u friends..
|
|
said this on 17 Oct 2008 12:38:51 PM IST
i accept private sectors.. bcoz ask rajesh.(M.G.R)..he s working mnc..
|
|
said this on 17 Oct 2008 12:43:07 PM IST
hi friendz.. To my view Government (public sector) are better when compared to Private Sectors. Both are Mutually Exclusive.
|
|
said this on 22 Oct 2008 7:36:32 AM IST
hi!!!
i accept that there must be a balance between both the sectors.it would be better if,in india,there is an understanding between the sectors for the development of our nation i.e. public sectors could implement new ideas and innovate new methods for the people`s welfare and comfort whereas private sectors can improve the nation`s economy.
|
|
said this on 15 Nov 2008 8:43:38 AM IST
i think govt.should also privatised rail way not fully but some part of it like 30% as it will be helpful to govt. by getting monetary help from private side.the govt. will have the major power so the poor people will not be exploited.
|
|
said this on 24 Nov 2008 9:45:21 AM IST
i think all above statements r right,according to my point of view public sector should not be privatised because if pub. sector will be privatised poor people can not bye those services which is provided by public sectos because of subsidy.pub sec provided services to that poor people who r using ration card.
|
|
said this on 23 Jan 2009 8:17:24 AM IST
i think both sector are well.as private sector u do not have power against public sector.our country 70% people are living in rural area he did not effort as private hospital,colleges etc.
public sector have good salary, good living standard ,getting a good colleges study so many thing.
|
|
said this on 20 Mar 2009 4:10:30 AM IST
it was simply gud nd it helped me a lot for my gd session
|
|
said this on 15 May 2009 11:53:02 AM IST
hey everybody,
I'll start by appreciating some of you who have written excellent comments. Should the public sector be privatized?
we can't say generalize and say yes or no as it is pretty subjective. when we say the public sectors should be privatized I'm sure we're just considering the quality of the services or products of a private sector, otherwise we don't have any reason for privatizing the public sector.
So as far as I'm concerned we should prepare a list of the qualities which has made the private sector very effective and efficient, for example..
1.private sectors are result orientated
2.employees are highly professional
3.Management will be really worried about the profit of the company which is directly related to their survival and profit and other compensation
4. Accountability and responsibilities... etc..
are few of them
what obvious is, when we privatize all the public sectors
chances off prices of going high is very likely.So, why cant we just say public sectors should be more efficient and result oriented so that we can ensure that we'll get all the benefits ( good quality services with cheaper price) which will help underprivileged and middle class people, because after all India has very less percentage of upper strata or elite class people....
can we say public sectors should be efficient and effective, and start thing and debating how to do that????!!!
|
|
said this on 21 May 2009 12:33:23 PM IST
fantastic.. i totally agree with ramesh
|
|
said this on 23 Jun 2009 11:46:17 AM IST
I totaly agree wat Ramesh said, By Seeing all the Comments, I also wanted to share........., Public Sector should not be privitized, if it get privitized, the rates will go high where the middle class people and low class people cant effort such thing,, so........ instead of this, public sector should improve their quality of service efficiently and effectively..... then everyone prefers public secotrs where they can get good quality with the lower price, by this way we can improve the profit of public sectors and people prefer to go public sector, this helps to the middle class people and low level people...
If anything wrong written........Please excuse me....
|
|
said this on 28 Jun 2009 9:45:25 PM IST
hi friends,
Ya though there are many dis-advantages or problems (related to delay of services,etc.) in the public sector, still people are benefitted in one way or the other through the various means of public norms which may not be in private undertaking. So. i feel that public sector need not be privatised as it may not benefit the people or if it is privatised the objective of privatisation may not the reach the people correctly.
|
|
said this on 29 Jul 2009 10:52:23 PM IST
Thanks, alot friends for helping me in clarifying the concept in a way to change my personal point of view about should public sector be privatised or it should'nt,
|
|
said this on 10 Aug 2009 4:20:23 PM IST
it is indeed a good topic to discuss.
i think that there should be mixed invovlement of both private & goverment in all sector ,, except few which are of prime importance like defence, finance, foreign affairs etc.
my idea is to incorporate private agencies in all public sectors giving them all responsibilites.
but they should be placed or headed by goverment authorities who shall regulate them.
|
|
said this on 06 Sep 2009 2:36:10 AM IST
Excellent Performance and views
|
|
said this on 08 Sep 2009 9:06:17 PM IST
This article is very useful for my GD preparation.Thanks a lot..
|
|
said this on 20 Sep 2009 5:47:09 PM IST
hello,
In my point of view some public sectors should be privatized.coz if all the sectors are privatized then there is hike in prices which in turn are out of range of the middle people and poor people. if all the sectors got private then this will lead to increase in poor population. and due to which our economy will go down and increase in poor people . so in my view all sectors are not privatized only some of the sectors like transportation, and banking gets privataized.
thanx.
|
|
said this on 05 Oct 2009 11:43:59 AM IST
Hi, If all department are convereted in to privataized, then the poor people has to suffer. For example, we can take Hospital, Normally for taking scan in Private hospital, they will charges five times more than the public hospital. And also if there is no public sector, The private people take this as a advantage and have there own rules. There will be no one to control.
|
|
said this on 15 Oct 2009 8:08:43 PM IST
i would like to comment on what Ashutosh said .........
that mukesh ambani is giving away petrol or vegetables at a lower cost.........but le me tell you the reason buddy , he is doing it cuz he is in competition with the public sector and just think if public sector wasn't der, he too wouldn't have missed the oppurtunity of rising prices and making more money outta it....personally what i feel is that something missing in public sector is the fear of loss of job........so all needed in a public sector is just that who is not working should be kicked out ............
|
|
said this on 26 Oct 2009 12:59:55 AM IST
fuck off ..........its bullshit group discussion.
|
|
said this on 26 Oct 2009 1:03:54 AM IST
saale yaha gd karne aaye hai bhai...........mooh chodi karne nahi samajhe BHO......
|
|
said this on 07 Nov 2009 10:30:05 AM IST
iam not agree with that public sector be privatised. public sector is worked more for poor people than for rich . the cost of service is very much nearer to poor. . what th egovt have to do to minimize the corruption & increase the more service.
|
|
said this on 19 Nov 2009 11:41:05 PM IST
I disagree with the view that public should be made private , yaah its true that public organization are little bit slow as the people working in it are working slow . But we cant be unfair to poor people , either as a customer or as a employee . Not every people are intelligent and not every people are rich . India is a secular country with every kind of people living here , we have to take all kind of people together . We cant throw slow people out of the country , or snatch his job coz he is slow . Well private organization does that mostly , once you show -ve performance . they will kick u out but not lke public organization . Public sector take needy step to hold their people .
Not all public sector are slow , our defence comes under gov organization , think if it goes private .
|
|
said this on 29 Dec 2009 2:06:45 AM IST
I wish to bring customer and employee perpective view to this topic. Privatization leads to better and efficient working as they are return oriented in their task, but they bring in such stringent clauses to the system that customers face the brunt of their interests. They are so much adamant for their returns that they even lay down the average employees just to show profits in thier books. This leads to chaos, which has multiple effects on whole economy.
The benefit that we see can reap is the standardization that they bring in and the innovative and benchmark practices to the business. We have seen that with advent of private players in the banking system we have a more flexible and efficient banking system. Privatization of electricity supply has led to increased revenues, less theft of electricty.
In the end i would like to say that we have to give the stick to the government, as it will only be saviour if these private players manipulate the system.
|
|
said this on 30 Dec 2009 3:27:18 PM IST
As far as a nation is considered its progress depends on how well its resources are utilized. And whether this results reaches its citizen in terms of employment and better way of life. For efficiency to come one has to make right decisions at right time. And one of the limitation with the govt bodies is the bureaucratic system which drags the decision and action, if they change their attitude to work then only results could be achieved. As per the current situation pvt players are far ahead of the govt undertakings. Every sector will be privatized in future, if not completely but definitely a certain part would be. So privatization should be brought in with control and transparency so that results of efficiency can take the country forward
|
|
said this on 04 Jan 2010 6:41:35 PM IST
Privatization of public sector. Lot depends of which sector we are talking about. Let me clarify few doubts in the primary stage. Can we expect all private hospitals in our cities in our town which do not have an entry for poor people, can we have only private sector telephone companies, can we have private companies have complete control on oil reserves, can we have all transport be provided by private sector and RTC vanishes, can we expect an private sector to take care of our defense. So as far as I'm concerned we should prepare a list of the qualities which has made the private sector very effective and efficient, for example.. 1.private sectors are result orientated 2.employees are highly professional 3.Management will be really worried about the profit of the company which is directly related to their survival and profit and other compensation 4. Accountability and responsibilities... etc.. are few of them what obvious is, when we privatize all the public sectors chances off prices of going high is very likely.So, why cant we just say public sectors should be more efficient and result oriented so that we can ensure that we'll get all the benefits ( good quality services with cheaper price) which will help underprivileged and middle class people, because after all India has very less percentage of upper strata or elite class people.... can we say public sectors should be efficient and effective, and start thing and debating how to do that????!!!
|
|
said this on 05 Jan 2010 11:23:38 AM IST
Anisha Basu.....Kolkata
Every one is talking abt the highest salary but nobody is talking abt the higher securities of gov. jobs....We sholud take few sectors for privatization...we cannot privatize the gov hospitals.bcz they charge a minimal cost to all the citizens. Underpriviledged peple or those who are from below Poverty Line they cannot afford much to the private nursinghomes....
In case of telecom industries also privatization shuold not be done..It is true that Reliance has introduced the mobile facility first but the indian gov. also providing us better facility in respect of landline as well as mobile at a cheap rate...further more Broadband facility is the most well liked facilty...
|
|
said this on 09 Jan 2010 12:53:37 PM IST
privatization will definitely lead to higher growth, economic development and better facilities but these could even be achieved by government on proper realization of their duties as they owe to the nation and to the people and both public and private sectors are mutually active forces in the economy which leads to healthy competition and better growth perspective.sectoral differentiation is a must for deciding over privatization as a country like India has a mix of economically differentiated class of people and the poor accounts for almost 40% of our population which has to be provided which the basic necessities, ration, housing(public sector), medical care and also the rest of the population are all not in a condition to afford to the rates of privatization so better facilities could also be provided by the government if we design a better management at all levels and hire well educated people, train the existing working staff and reduce the existing red tapism across the public sectors.The existence of both the sectors in the economy will efficiently lead to development and growth.
|
|
said this on 17 Jan 2010 9:45:00 PM IST
i m not agree to many thought because in public sector exams is very hard compare to private sector exams , so in public sector employee are able to do anything but our system is wrong . we need only to correcting . we are seeing many public sector companies they r top in ranking like ongc . bhel etc . i think no need to privatization to public sector . otherwise in future we cannot stopped the prises and cannot get subsidy.
|
|
said this on 01 Feb 2010 1:45:03 PM IST
hi Privtation.....its sound very attractive.bt in India if you privtatise thn you hv to mke all p/e employed with good salary.Bt in India its tk time or nt going to b hapn.if all public sector b privatise thn autimatically theafting,murder corpuction e.t.c will increase. n i dont thnk p/e want this.........&obviously it depnd on sectr 2 sectr........we cnt privatise army,all hospitals,,,etc.............
|
|
said this on 02 Feb 2010 1:36:24 AM IST
alot of people would say that privatisation will totally eradicate all the problems but his is not true inspite it may create alot of problems for a nation like india which is in the developing stage imagine if govt hospita;s are privatised,where will poors go,think of he privatisation oy BSNL
private sector will enjoy the monopolyt and in the end consumers are the sufferer.so inspite of privatising all public bodies the necessary improvement should be done in the functioning of public sector.
|
|
said this on 19 Feb 2010 7:57:57 PM IST
yes ,to some extent public sector be privtise........... articles such as food ,petroleum and necessory goods of human need should not be privatise but article such as distribution of electricity in citied should come in privatization fpr better use of it....
|
|
said this on 25 Feb 2010 6:32:14 PM IST
Hi I want to say that private sectors are working well but in public sector they have to do or act like a private sector this is not the fact that public sectors should be privatized.public sectors shoud have change their way of work as i told like private sectors.their are lots of articles like just someone said that education facility , medical facility etc are some need of "aam aadmi"so these things have control of public sector.Because private sector have charged high to people which can not be affordable by poor people
|
|
said this on 28 Feb 2010 12:04:07 AM IST
Hi I think it is impossible for privatization of public sector because mainly poor people are depend on public sector if u calculate then u can analysis in India there more over 60%-70% peoples belong to low salary structure. Put this thing in this way public sector is a part of every indian .
|
|
said this on 17 Mar 2010 10:52:17 PM IST
as of today's scenario, v c tht the fiscal deficit is 6.4%.so to reduce the deficit the govt is plannin to disinvest so as to raise an amt of rs.40000 cr.thus, in today's scenario privatisation has bcm essential for the growth of indian economy.
|
|
said this on 20 Mar 2010 8:27:48 PM IST
i read some speech all are relevent to topic and interesting suggstion, and really this type of article will surely remove the unawareness about the topic.
thanks to the writer of these topic.
|
|
said this on 14 Jun 2010 2:40:27 PM IST
Nowadays public or any government institutions are not going well and they treat the people very badly. The only thing is we can't question them if they converted into private definetly they will sincere to their work and the public will also question them.
|
|
said this on 01 Jul 2010 12:27:08 AM IST
private n public sector both has their own significance. the prime motive of the private sector is PROFIT and so all the responsibilities cannot be given in their hands. but still we cannot deny the fact that they provide better service. whereas the public sector besides making profit is accountable to the people.
|
|
said this on 04 Aug 2010 1:23:30 PM IST
yes according to my opinion privetization is imp but in few sector because private sector provide a better srvice,whereas the public sector take so much time but every one can not able to get a private srvice.
|
|
said this on 17 Aug 2010 10:12:54 AM IST
Yes of course privatization of public sector leads to some healthy changes in an organization. But some public sector should not be privatized because the poor people can not entry.
|
|
said this on 20 Aug 2010 9:11:22 PM IST
I think every sector should be privatized when dealing with India... According to my idea, India with such a huge population should be completely privatized because the cost of any thing will be affordable when there is huge costumers for it...
Think of the cost for making a phone calls when there were privatized in the first and had very little costumers they were sky rocketing... but think of the better service provided now with a price for even a fisherman can afford daily...
So i think privatizing the sector with large costumers is a must... or this country will face a lot of struggle to become a developed nation...
By the way i don't mean the govt should completely ignore and go out... it should be just there monitoring all sectors mainly the dangerous sectors like the nuke power stations and the defense sectors, the private companies develop them rapidly and the government take care of its corrects functionality....
|
|
said this on 24 Aug 2010 4:13:51 PM IST
i agree with ur command
|
Author)